Skip to content

Hi there, Trinidad Guardian folk

20-May-10

Good to see you again. Glad you enjoy the Limes.


To the editors and reporters of the Trinidad Guardian who might be reading this:

Hi. The Liming House here. Today I happened to catch the attention of the folk(s) behind @TriniGuardian.  As I’m inclined to do whenever I read one of your pieces, I was engaging in some stream of consciousness invective, as below:

“most ‘Neediest Cases’”? Srsly? RT @TriniGuardian The Fund was organised to identify the ten most “Neediest Cases” in T&T…

Dear @TriniGuardian: you need to hire some bloody editors. http://bit.ly/9IeSJ4

And what is with this ‘Karen’ and ‘Anil’ nonsense? You all used to pitch marble? http://bit.ly/cUES62

Could you also hire people who who can put a sentence together @TriniGuardian? This is appalling http://bit.ly/d1pajB

Other weighed in, via RTs and replies:

seldo @theliminghouse Do not get me (and especially not @eparillon) started on the illiteracy of T&T newspapers. The Express is even worse.

eparillon @theliminghouse @seldo that example doesn’t even seem that bad by Trini news standards, honestly.

eparillon @theliminghouse The one about the PSA guy who embezzled all that money. And I agree on the weeping.

eparillon @theliminghouse I’m not saying it was literate, but I did end the article knowing marginally more than when I started it.

eparillon @theliminghouse That’s a BIG victory by Trini press standards.

To which I responded:

@eparillon which example? There are numerous. Those were selected arbitrarily. In general, I avoiding reading the Trini press. Makes me cry.

@eparillon The piece on the PSA guy was all kinds of terrible, made worse by the fact the reporters involved thought they were oh- so-clever

@seldo Oh, I’ve written about them before. But it’s been a while. Time for a fresh dissection.

By that time, your Twitter folk(s) had clocked on:

TriniGuardian Please know that we appreciate your comments and opinion and we will look into this matter @theliminghouse

Thanks @theliminghouse for the observation, we acknowledge your comment

TriniGuardian @theliminghouse is there anything further you wish us to assist you with at this moment. We do our best to complete our duties…

Of course, there’s history here, something to which I alluded in my responses:

@TriniGuardian Still waiting to hear back from you about previous queries, so I won’t hold my breath.

Further to hiring better editors, teaching reporters how to write and basic fact-checking, see also http://bit.ly/azbfgp @TriniGuardian

As for that history? Let’s go back to September 2009, when I published  dissection of a piece of work written by Richard Lord on alcohol consumption in Trinidad. That post got picked up by Global Voices and various Twitterati, and as with today, the folks behind @TriniGuardian promised to “look into it.”

Never heard back.

But listen, don’t take my outbursts personally.

Actually, scratch that. You should bloody well take this personally. As a rule, the quality of reporting in your newspaper and on your website is abysmal. Your pages are replete with spelling mistakes, typos and grammar that would shock a half-decent primary school student; errors of fact and omission; opinion pieces masquerading as news; pieces without bylines;  stories and photographs ripped from the pages and websites of other publications without attribution.

Have you no professional pride? Do you care not at all about getting things right? Do you pay no heed to the fact that strong, hard-hitting and objective media are essential to the development of a country and its people?

Do any of you even read?

What the hell is going on with media in Trinidad and Tobago? Seriously. Get a grip, guys and gals. Because this is beyond embarrassing.

Back in March 2009, I wrote the following but never posted it:

I blame the journalists. I blame the reporters. I blame the editors, the subeditors and the production desks. I blame the anchors, the sound engineers and the camera operators. I blame the owners and the advertisers. I blame the readers, the viewers, the listeners.

Because Trinidadian media suck.

That about sums it up.

Corporate dreadlocs and other stories

19-Apr-10

Back in 2008, I wrote a piece that argued thus, on the subject of my preferred “hairstyle”:

I am my hair. I am challenging, I am defiant, I do not apologize.

And the next time some Wall Street multimillionaire or Oxbridge-educated middle-aged perpetually entitled white British editor encounters a twenty-something <insertracehere> woman from the Caribbean, or someone with locs, he will pause.

He will pause because he will remember someone else who was more than the stereotype.

Someone who was more than just her hair, or her ancestry, or her age, or her gender, or her accent, or her taste in shoes.

Fast forward two years, and an interesting synchronicity of events. The first, an emailed question from a long-lost acquaintance, someone who knew me from my “long curly light brown hair” past and who I have not seen in a nigh on a decade: “how did you manage to grow a ras?”

The second, a post on the kimaspeak blog on the subject of “Corporate Locks” (H/T PM):

In spite of all the above bravado, though, the idea of bringing locs into my workplace terrified me. This was not Grenada, the Caribbean. This was London. This was the Square Mile, possibly the most conservative area in London; this was my office where there are not too many black people in the first place. Was I making the right decision personally but a wrong one professionally? I have worn braids and cornrows in the office before- my thinking was- they need to get used to it- but am I possibly pushing the boundaries a little bit too far?

Which felt like reading a transcript of my own internal monologues.

Like kimaspeak, I have worked and lived in London, and have been a part of the financial world there – an insular, conservative (and Conservative) world that is also overwhelmingly white and male. My employers, my colleagues, my contacts, did not know quite how to react to the educated, ‘well spoken’, dreadlocked Trinidadian female of indistinct racial origin and something of an ‘attitude problem’, in so far as I failed entirely to cower in the presence of those around me.

And it was much the same at the university I attended, where those on campus had a hard time figuring out why I was so unlike either the “Black British” or the “yardies”, why I did things like run for student office or speak up in class about the fallacy of homogenising “the Third World”. I bemused them still further with my attempts to explain why an “Afro-Caribbean” society did little to serve the students from the latter region who did not share either a cultural or even necessarily an ethnic background with those ostensibly represented by the “Afro”.

Because like kimaspeak, I too have a swagger – the swagger of a certain type of overachieving “prestige school” alumnus – and the bravado of someone who had never been indoctrinated with the pernicious idea that one’s place in society was contingent on the colour of one’s skin. Someone who had never been damned with faint praise  – “oh, but you speak so well”; someone who had never been expected to fail or written off as a delinquent on the basis of an abundance of melatonin.

And yet.

And yet when I am getting ready for a day filled with meetings, I pause. If I wrap my hair, as I am wont to do, what ‘signal’ with that give? How will my contacts react when they see me for the first time? Does this look too ‘ethnic’? Can I really moderate that panel at a conference where the only other people of my skintone will be serving canapés while I look the way I do?

These are the kinds of questions with which I assail myself. This is what living in the UK and Europe and the US has done to me.

I am the only person at my organisation who looks like me. Back to kimaspeak’s post:

Should you hide or change your hair to “fit in”? And the answer is poignant: it depends on the company, look at how top managers, especially blacks, wear their hair.

This led me to a dead end. What if your company has no black top managers? What then?

What then? Then I pause, take a deep breath, and decide I will wrap my hair if I feel like it.

Because there need to be more people like me – non-white, non-male – challenging the assumptions of what someone who does what I do should look like, or sound like, or dress like.

Swagger.


Alcoa negotiator being investigated for bribery by US/UK prosecutors

06-Apr-10

Not that anyone in the local media should be asking questions of our politicians, or anything…

From the Wall Street Journal:

U.S. and U.K. prosecutors are investigating a prominent Canadian businessman for criminal money laundering and bribery as part of a two-year investigation centering on Alcoa Inc., the metals giant, according to people familiar with the matter.

The prosecutors have unearthed new documents that they believe show the involvement of Victor Dahdaleh, a longtime agent of Alcoa who helped negotiate contracts with companies in the Middle East and elsewhere, according to the people familiar with the matter.

No charges have been filed against Mr. Dahdaleh, a Canadian citizen in his 60s who lives in London. His lawyer declined comment.

<snip>

Since 2008, U.S. prosecutors have been investigating whether Pittsburgh-based Alcoa was involved in bribing government officials in the Persian Gulf state of Bahrain in exchange for business in possible violation of the 1977 U.S. Foreign Corrupt Practices Act, according to people familiar with the matter. Prosecutors are looking at Alcoa’s relationship with Aluminum Bahrain BSC, a Bahrain government-owned manufacturing company also known as Alba, these people said. Alba has one of the world’s largest aluminum smelters and bought raw materials from Alcoa.

<snip>

Prosecutors now have private financial records that they believe show that from 2001 to 2005, a company controlled by Mr. Dahdaleh made several million dollars in payments to the personal bank account of a former Alba senior executive, according to the people familiar with the matter.

Speaking of corruption in the Caribbean, can anyone point me to mentions of the following case anywhere in the Guardian, Newsday or Express?

United States v. Sam P. Wallace Co., Inc. (D.P.R. 1983)131
United States v. Alfonson A. Rodriguez (D.P.R. 1983)132

NATURE OF THE BUSINESS Mechanical, electrical and civil construction by Sam P. Wallace Co.
(“Wallace Co.”), a Texas corporation and an issuer.

BUSINESS LOCATION Trinidad and Tobago.

PAYMENT

1. Amount of the value Series of payments, totaling $1.391 million.
2. Amount of business related to the payment Not stated.
3. Intermediary None.
4. The foreign official The Chairman of the Trinidad and Tobago Racing Authority (“TTRA”), an
agency of the government of Trinidad and Tobago.

INFLUENCE TO BE OBTAINED To obtain and retain a contract from TTRA to construct the
grandstand and receiving building of the Caroni Racetrack project in Trinidad.

ENFORCEMENT
1. Amount of the fine Wallace Co. pled guilty to three counts under the accounting sections of
the FCPA and was fined $30,000.
2. Individuals charged and their relationship with the business Rodriguez, president of
Wallace Co., pled guilty to the single count of bribery of a foreign official under the FCPA and
received a sentence of three years’ probation and a $10,000 fine.
3. Other crimes charged Wallace Co. pled guilty to one count under the Currency and Foreign
Transactions Reporting Act and was fined $500,000. The SEC also brought actions against
Wallace Co. and Rodriguez.


Virgin Atlantic and the Travel Foundation dig a deeper hole for themselves, continue to condescend to Caribbean youth

11-Feb-10

In response to my indictment of the ‘charitable’ efforts of Virgin Atlantic and the Travel Foundation to turn a generation of young people in the Caribbean into fisherfolk and bee-keepers, a Virgin representative posted the following in the comments:

The Travel Foundation and Virgin Atlantic were concerned to read your comments on our work together in the Caribbean. We believe that the projects will bring huge benefits and stimulate entrepreneurship along with addressing pressing environmental issues. Here is further information which should allay any concerns and provide more information.
You are correct in saying that tourism is key to the region’s economy. In 2008, travel and tourism provided over 2.1m jobs and 15% of the region’s GDP but there is an opportunity to spread the benefits tourism brings further.
There are significant issues with youth unemployment in the Caribbean with as many as 30% of 20-24 year olds out of work.
The projects that we have chosen to develop may seem small, but they are very significant. They link to the globally-important environmental issues of waste management, fish and bee conservation – issues that are vital to food security.
By creating new, small-scale, local business opportunities many of the skills learned can be applied to any business which gives young people independence and choice.
These initiatives will offer choice, new opportunities and new skills for entrepreneurship with the aim that this will create new jobs and opportunities for income generation.

To which I have this to say:

I did not say that tourism is key to the region’s economy. In fact, most of the islands are attempting to diversify away from a dependency on tourism, particularly in light of the ongoing global financial crisis.

You – Virgin and the Travel Foundation – are talking your book. Tourism in the Caribbean is to your benefit.

Your projects are not merely small; they are insulting. The Caribbean’s youth are educated, technically savvy, computer-literate, driven and ambitious. But you think ‘small scale’ fish farming is more important than developing financial services, media, advertising, marketing, manufacturing…

Pardon me if I don’t buy into your argument that relying on the fickle tastes of British tourists gives my peers “independence and choice”.

Your pitch might work on someone who has not grown up in the region, who has no idea of the scale and speed of the development in the Caribbean, someone whose idea of these islands is ‘sun, sea, sand and subservience.’ I am not that person. You, however, quite obviously are.

Virgin Atlantic’s patronising ‘help the Caribbean’ campaign

09-Feb-10

Hats off to Virgin Atlantic and the Travel Foundation for rendering me completely speechless:

The Travel Foundation cares for the people and places we all love to visit. Sustainable tourism can help protect traditions, culture and the natural environment – the things that make your holiday special. It can also improve the lives of the people who live in tourist destinations so they are happy and able to give you a warm welcome.

And the great news is that all of this gives you an even better holiday experience as well as ensuring there are great places for us all to visit, for generations to come.

We’re changing lives in the Caribbean – Over the next three years, the Travel Foundation will work on the profound social and environmental effect of tourism in the Caribbean, where we fly 800,000 customers a year. They will support entrepreneurial business development among disadvantaged youth, particularly in the areas of craft making, beekeeping and fishing.

Our fantastic beekeeping project will help young people learn about traditional skills so they can produce honey to sell to the tourism industry. This will aid the conservation of the honey bee and give you an even sweeter taste of the Caribbean.

Tilapia fish farming is an educational programme that will teach about over-fishing and help young people develop small businesses, enabling them to sell farmed fish to local hotels and restaurants. This will demonstrate an alternative livelihood to traditional fishing and allow you to enjoy fresh fish from a sustainable source while you’re having a fabulous holiday.

Our craft making project will teach new skills, helping young people produce crafts from recycled materials collected from hotels, thereby reducing waste and offering new business opportunities. So, in the near future, you’ll also get to buy hand-made souvenirs in a new craft centre – a unique reminder of your time away!

That text, taken from the airline’s website, was also included in Virgin’s in-flight ‘Seatback’ magazine, which is where I first saw it. I am incensed by the campaign, however well-intentioned those behind it may purport to be.

Both Virgin and the Travel Foundation appear to think that the only opportunities for ‘disadvantaged youth’ in the Caribbean are in ‘craft making, beekeeping and fishing.’ Gosh, development has just passed those backward-but-smiling natives right by!

Both the language and the substance of the text contrive to reinforce the image of the Caribbean as a homogenous, tourist-dependent bloc, and of its people as suited only to such ‘traditional skills’ as fish farming and craft making. The emphasis on the contributions of these poor, straw-hat wearing Caribbean folk to the hotel and restaurant industries in the region is even more infuriating.

Thanks, Virgin and the Travel Foundation, for reducing the ambitions and potential of an entire generation of young people in the Caribbean to kowtowing to tourists.

Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0
This work by The Liming House is licensed under a Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0.