Category Archives: Business & Finance

Moody’s reviews First Citizens’ ratings

Moody’s, the ratings agency, is reviewing the credit ratings of First Citizens Bank Limited for a possible downgrade. The agency has been conducting a broad review of global banks, so this is not entirely surprising.

Here are the comments from Moody’s, any highlighting is my own:

New York, June 02, 2009 — Moody’s Investors Service has placed the A1 long term local currency deposit rating of First Citizens Bank Limited on review for possible downgrade in light of its global review of systemic support for bank ratings in the context of the current credit crisis. As a result, Moody’s also placed on review for possible downgrade the A1 ratings for the foreign currency debt of First Citizens Bank (St Lucia) that is guaranteed by First Citizens. The bank’s C- bank financial strength rating, Prime-1 short term local currency deposit rating, and Baa1/Prime-2 foreign currency deposit ratings are not affected by this review and have been affirmed.

Government-owned First Citizens is the only bank rated by Moody’s in Trinidad and Tobago and as such is the only bank affected by the reassessment of systemic support. At present the bank’s local currency deposit and foreign currency debt ratings incorporate three notches of systemic support. “The review of First Citizens’ debt and deposit ratings will consider the extent to which the government of Trinidad and Tobago’s ability to support its banking system, should such support be needed, is converging with the government’s own debt capacity as a result of the ongoing global economic and credit crisis,” says Jeanne Del Casino, a Moody’s Vice President and Senior Credit Officer.

The rating agency believes that most governments are at least as likely, if not more likely, to support their banking systems as they are to service their own debt — a view that has traditionally led to bank ratings often benefiting from significant uplift due to systemic support. However, as the financial crisis continues, the capacity of a country and its central bank to support the nation’s banks converges with, and is constrained by, the government’s own debt capacity.

Moody’s has previously used the local currency deposit ceiling (LCDC) as the main input for its assessment of the ability of a national government to support its banks. Although anchoring the probability of support at the LCDC is appropriate in many circumstances — regarding the provision of liquidity to a selected number of institutions over a short period of time — this might overestimate the capacity of a central bank to support financial institutions in the event that a banking crisis may become both truly systemic and protracted.

The rating agency will review the specific circumstances of Trinidad and Tobago to determine the appropriate systemic support for Trinidadian bank ratings. Moody’s will reassess the level of systemic support for First Citizens to determine to what extent the systemic support incorporated in its ratings should be more closely aligned to the government’s local currency bond rating of Baa1. This approach is outlined in Moody’s special comment “Financial Crisis More Closely Aligns Bank Credit Risk and Government Ratings in Non-Aaa Countries” available on www.moodys.com.

Factors that the rating agency will consider in its assessment of systemic support include (i) the size of the banking system in relation to government resources, (ii) the level of stress in the banking system, (iii) the foreign currency obligations of the banking system relative to the government’s own foreign exchange resources, and (iv) changes to the government’s political patterns and priorities.

Moody’s noted that the size of Trinidad and Tobago’s banking system is modest relative to the government’s resources. Credit stress in the banking system has been muted so far during the current financial crisis, though banking fundamentals are experiencing some pressure in light of the economic slowdown in Trinidad and Tobago. Government actions during past crises are indicative of the Trinidadian government’s high focus on financial system stability. During Trinidad’s financial crisis of the early 1990s, the government acted purposefully to contain the potential contagion effects of troubled institutions in the market. More recently, in February 2009, the government took control of three local financial institutions owned by CL Financial Limited, the country’s largest conglomerate, to help stem funding pressures at that company.

In affirming First Citizens’ C- bank financial strength rating Moody’s said that the bank continues to exhibit sound profitability, liquidity, and capital adequacy which position it well to cope with potential asset quality deterioration in the context of the economic downturn. Moody’s noted that the ratings review is unlikely to lead to more than a one notch change in First Citizens’ foreign currency debt and local currency deposit ratings. The rating agency expects to conclude the review over the next few weeks.


S&P says may cut ratings on FCB and Republic Bank

S&P, which said today it was considering downgrading T&T’s sovereign credit rating, is also scrutinising the ratings of both First Citizens Bank and Republic Bank due to the fallout from the CL Financial bailout.

Here are the statements, any emphasis/explanations mine:

S&P: First Citizens Bank Ltd. ‘BBB+/A-2’ Rating Put On CreditWatch Negative

[“CreditWatch Negative” means that a downgrade is likely within the next three months, pending further information/review]

[A triple-B rating is borderline investment grade; the institution is considered ‘satisfactory’]

MEXICO CITY Feb. 3, 2009–Standard & Poor’s Ratings Services said today that it placed its ‘BBB+/A-2’ counterparty credit rating on First Citizens Bank Ltd. on CreditWatch with negative implications.

Standard & Poor’s also said that it placed its ‘BBB+’ ratings on the $100 million bonds from First Citizens and First Citizens (St. Lucia) Ltd. on Credit Watch negative.

The CreditWatch placement follows Trinidad and Tobago’s announcement on Jan. 30, 2009, that it will assume control of or provide support to several key subsidiaries of CL Financial Group (CLFG), a large Trinidadian financial conglomerate. According to the central bank, CLFG’s financial condition has deteriorated because of related-party transactions, high-risk investments, and high leveraging of the group’s assets. The central bank has announced that it will take control of CLFG’s flagship bank, Clico Investment Bank (CIB), transfer its assets and deposits liabilities to First Citizens Bank (wholly owned by the government), and revoke CIB’s banking license. The government has announced that CLFG will divest assets, including its shares in Republic Bank Ltd. (a 55% share) and Methanol Holdings Trinidad Ltd., to First Citizens Bank and the government to make up the statutory fund shortfall, with the government backstopping any deficiency.

“We expect to resolve the CreditWatch status of the ratings when there is further clarification of First Citizens Bank participation in the bail out process and the impact that this will have on the bank’s overall creditworthiness,” said Standard & Poor’s credit analyst Angelica Bala.

S&P: Republic Bank Ltd. ‘BBB/A-2’ Rating Put On CreditWatch Developing

MEXICO CITY Feb. 3, 2009–Standard & Poor’s Ratings Services said today that it placed its ‘BBB/A-2’ counterparty credit rating on Republic Bank Ltd. on CreditWatch with developing implications.

The CreditWatch placement follows Trinidad and Tobago’s announcement on Jan. 30, 2009, that it will assume control of or provide support to several key subsidiaries of the CL Financial Group (CLFG), a large Trinidadian financial conglomerate that owns 55% of Republic Bank Shares. The government has announced that CLFG will divest assets, including its 55% share in Republic Bank Ltd., to First Citizens Bank and the government to make up the statutory fund shortfall, with the government backstopping any deficiency.

“We expect to resolve the CreditWatch status of the ratings when there is further information on how the transaction is going to be done and the implications to Republic Bank, currently the largest bank in the country,” noted Standard & Poor’s credit analyst Angelica Bala.


CL Financial bailout threatens T&T’s credit rating

From credit rating agency Standard & Poor’s on Tuesday (emphasis and in-line explanations mine):

NEW YORK, Feb. 3, 2009–Standard & Poor’s Ratings Services said today that it placed its ‘A/A-1’ foreign-currency and ‘A+/A-1’ local-currency sovereign credit ratings on the Republic of Trinidad and Tobago on CreditWatch with negative implications.

[Credit watch with negative implications means the ratings agency is considering downgrading T&T’s existing credit rating; any subsequent rating action is normally taken within three months. A sovereign’s credit rating is important because it determines (among other things) how much that country will pay to borrow in the international debt markets. Essentially, a credit rating is an assessment of a country’s creditworthiness; it is an indicator of that country’s willingness and ability to repay its debts. As a benchmark, S&P rates the United States as triple-A – the highest possible rating – while Jamaica is currently rated B]

“The CreditWatch placement follows the government’s announcement on Jan. 30, 2009, that it will assume control of or provide support to several key subsidiaries of the CL Financial Group (CLFG), a large Trinidadian financial conglomerate,” explained Standard & Poor’s credit analyst Roberto Sifon-Arevalo. According to the central bank, CLFG’s financial condition has deteriorated because of related-party transactions, high-risk investments, and high leveraging of the group’s assets. The central bank has announced that it will take control of CLFG’s flagship bank, Clico Investment Bank (CIB), transfer its assets and deposits liabilities to wholly government-owned First Citizens Bank, and revoke CIB’s banking license. CLFG has also disclosed that its insurance companies–CLICO Insurance Co. Ltd. and British American Insurance Co. Ltd.–have sizeable statutory fund deficits. The government has announced that CLFG will divest assets, including its 55% share in Republic Bank Ltd. and share in Methanol Holdings Trinidad Ltd., to First Citizens Bank and the government to make up the statutory fund shortfall, with the government backstopping any deficiency.

“We will resolve the CreditWatch status of the ratings once we can estimate the potential fiscal cost to the government, the broader damage to its financial system, and any impairment to the island’s medium-term growth prospects,” Mr. Sifon-Arevalo added. Trinidad and Tobago enters this CLFG intervention with general government assets exceeding debt by 4.5% of GDP in 2008, a substantial improvement from a net debt position of 20% in 2003. The country’s external position has also strengthened, with net external liabilities of 6% of current account receipts in 2008, down from 134% in 2003. The government’s saving of part of its gas windfall in its Heritage and Stabilization Fund during this period accounts for its fiscal buffer and the country’s improved international investment position.

Further reading:
Sovereign ratings in the Caribbean – An S&P report from May 2007